Is Perth Falling Behind in Modern Photography?

Is Perth Falling Behind in Modern Photography?

Entering photography competitions can be both exciting and intimidating. For many photographers, one of the biggest frustrations is the inconsistency in judging — what wins one competition might barely make a shortlist in another.

So, why does that happen?

The Human Side of Judging

Photography judging is as subjective as it is technical. Every judge brings their own creative lens — some are drawn to bold colour and composition, while others look for emotional storytelling or fine art subtlety. The result? Two technically perfect images might be scored very differently depending on who’s behind the panel.

Local competitions in Perth often have smaller judging pools, which can mean judges know entrants or share a similar photographic community. On the other hand, national or international competitions usually feature external judges with broader experience, which can bring more neutrality — though not necessarily less subjectivity.

The Perth Perspective

Over the years, I’ve noticed a recurring pattern — and I’m certainly not the only one who’s seen it. Many photographers here in Perth feel that local judging tends to favour safe, conventional imagery rather than rewarding bold or creative experimentation.

There’s a sense that modern styles and storytelling-based work — the kind that pushes boundaries or uses light, tone, and post-processing creatively — often get overlooked in favour of technically correct but familiar scenes. I’ve heard countless stories of photographers who submit something imaginative, receive dismissive feedback, and then retreat to producing “the safe shot” simply to please judges or peers.

It’s disheartening, because the appetite for creativity is there.
In my workshops, I see people of all ages eager to learn how to shoot differently — to experiment in-camera, to play with shadows, slow shutters, reflections, and unusual compositions. They want to break away from the predictable postcard shot. Yet, when competitions undervalue that experimentation, it can discourage photographers from continuing to explore their individuality.

From broader research and conversations online, it’s clear that Perth’s photography scene is often viewed as lagging behind the east coast when it comes to innovation and creative diversity. Cities like Melbourne and Sydney seem more open to modern interpretation and conceptual work — where artistic risk is celebrated, not penalised.

What Makes Judging Feel Fair

Transparency helps everyone. Clear judging criteria, a diverse panel, and even minimal feedback all contribute to a fairer experience. When competitions publish their judging process and the names of their judges, entrants gain trust — and insight into what to expect.

Digital-only judging differs from print judging too. A photograph that pops on screen might lose impact in print if colour calibration or paper choice isn’t right. Understanding which format a competition uses can help you prepare accordingly.

Moving Forward

Perth has an incredible creative community — and I believe we’re ready for a shift. Encouraging judges, clubs, and competitions to embrace modern photographic expression will help Western Australia keep pace with the rest of the country.

Competitions should inspire photographers to take risks, to think differently, and to see beyond the obvious — because that’s where the art of photography truly lives.

Written by Claire Gilham-Martin, Perth-based photographer and educator passionate about helping photographers rediscover creativity through camera craft, light, and storytelling.